18 Comments
User's avatar
Kellye's avatar

Beautifully written. I, too, felt very nervous yesterday. I was home with my two dogs and I said out loud, “This is such an important moment for this trainer. If she can’t win, I hope she stops trying and gallops home safely.” I couldn’t stand to watch but listened to the fractions and then heard the words that she had the race won. That’s when I looked up at the TV, clapped my hands, and then saw her fall.

Condolences to everyone who loved her.

Jeff Klenner's avatar

It certainly transported me back to the same sick, horrified feeling I had after Go For Wand’s race in the Breeders’ Cup. Despite being an avid fan for 50 years, these moments haunt me and leave me questioning my love for the sport.

I don’t know how anyone could not feel that way in the aftermath of yesterday. She was clearly tiring but, at the same time, she was all heart in continuing to dig down deeper. I could feel the danger that was present in these conditions in real-time and was absolutely devastated that my concern proved to be warranted. I hate it that I was shocked but not surprised. Something feels incredibly wrong about that, even though the rational side of my brain knows that the same sort of thing can conceivably happen in a pasture (without human involvement involving racing). Nobody wants to feel as though they’re part of anything that would contribute to such a horrific tragedy taking place to these majestic animals we so treasure. So I’m left with the same gut-wrenching soul searching that has taken place after similar incidents in the past.

We all dread these moments when they invariably occur from time to time. I’m just not certain whether it haunts other people as much as it haunts me. I’ve had a lifelong love/hate relationship with sport/business of racing for this AND a multitude of other reasons.

Robin C C's avatar

Beautiful work as usual Chuck. My heart goes out to the trainer and the connections of this horse. The racing gods can be so cruel 😢😢

Baird's avatar

I feel the same way about not being a fan of any particular horse except from a breeding perspective.. There is a NY State Bred mare named Sayoh whose pedigree I thought was pretty intriguing and I wonder why nobody has picked up on that.

Joseph Heichelbech's avatar

Chuck I felt sick yesterday she was special and I feel so sorry for the whole team. I Love horses and always will. I felt like I was right there walking beside you you wrote that so Good. Take care.

David Schneck's avatar

Very well written Chuck

Sal Carcia's avatar

I can’t imagine anyone else who could have written this tribute any better.

Deepdish's avatar

Well done Chuck- your writing is fantastic and captures the emotion we are all feeling. JD

Ann's avatar

I needed to read this..

Thanks, Chuck 🏇🏿🥲

Anthony Montanino's avatar

Great piece Chuck… I watched on TV and couldn’t believe my eyes….I saw Ruffian go down in that match race on Live TV, and that’s what I went back to in my head. Both situations left an indelible mark in my mind.

Alan's avatar

Wow...I don’t anyone could’ve said it any better.

Stephen Nagler's avatar

The easy part is the shock and the horrifying moment unfolding. Trying to lend perspective is so much harder. Thanks as always for generously sharing yours’ with us.

Paula Keim's avatar

Oh, and then there’s that eternal lake a fire then I definitely not gonna join that team so fight Evil every day and thanks for helping me with my Armor i’m still standing now. I gotta do it. It’s the first time I’m doing this, but I’m gonna Ephesians 6:10-20 I never read the Bible till a year ago I liked pretending to read the Bible,you and I read the Bible at the hospital In Saratoga We went a lot of places surrounded by horses and dogs so and I can’t that cat named monkey alot of great people a lot of good times anyway amen so it should be that’s all I have to say about this at this time, but not all I have to say🫶🏻

Paula Keim's avatar

I miss you, Chuck. I just do I miss you Chuck. Thanks so much. You know me hanging out with you surrounded by dogs and horses and Hall Of Fame trainers. How about it? You’re not hanging out with OJ are you?????? I don’t think he I don’t think so. Say hi to my brother Steve I wonder if he’s hanging out there too, and there are different places y’all go. Some people are chosen to go to where great people like you are and then some just stay in this wandering around place where they don’t know where they are and they are bewildered and can’t be fun so I wanna go where you are so anyway geez I’ll just continue to walk that path of righteous so grateful to the Healing School and the people in my life that have brought me to the Bible in the word in Jesus and amen that’s all I have to say about that at this time but I miss you and I love you thank you to the River Church in Tampa the Healing School I wouldn’t have been able to see you Chuck before your departed certainly me think about you every day. Dang your pictures is all over the boys so it’s hard tonight. Talk to you anyway I listen to your podcast so I can hear your voice chip in Earl and Woody Harley Hank of a Dogs go to heaven. by the way, who is this woman talking not your voice 😂

James A's avatar

Chuck, thank you for this heartfelt tribute to Maple Leaf Mel. If you were 30 yards away from Go For Wand, I was about 50. I felt so awful on that chilly Saturday afternoon at Belmont 33 years ago. However, I must say that Brendan Walsh handled this impossible situation with all of the Class that Ron McAnally displayed after that BC Distaff. Nevertheless, now that you let us know that Billy Badgett was present on Saturday, I must question why a good man such as him had to tortured again with such incredible sadness.

Marilee Herrera's avatar

Beautifully written my friend Chuck Simon... I'm thankful to have witnessed her in person but wish it would have been a different race.... may she rest easy!!!💔💔💔🏇🏾🏇🏾🏇🏾